Promises, Promises . . .

Way back when she was in prison, should Hester have made her promise to Chillingworth in the first place?  In making/breaking her promise, who did Hester betray more, Arthur Dimmesdale or Roger Chillingworth?  Talk a little bit about your answer, and also discuss whether or not she should have been forgiven.  

Your response in the comment box is unmoderated, so it should appear immediately.